| Prosecutors (Day 1, October 3) |
Defenders (Day 2, October 5) |
Jurors (Day 3, October 8) |
| Jenna |
Kyle |
Miracle |
| Dan |
Samantha |
Danielle |
| Stephan |
Benjamin |
Isaac |
| Cassandra |
Allee |
Jennifer |
| Matthew |
Anna |
Apsara |
| Keaton |
Robert |
Justin |
| Maxwell |
Keely |
Aubrey |
| Trevor |
Johnathan |
Kris |
| Jessica |
Melinda |
Zack (Wyatt) |
| Zachary Honzell |
Cody |
Brett |
| Kim |
James Cowley |
| Prosecutors (Day 1, October 3) | Defenders (Day 2, October 5) | Jurors (Day 3, October 8) |
| Mary | James |
Chris |
| Samuel |
Michael |
Tiffony |
| Toni |
Jared |
Eric |
| Russ |
Josh |
Cody |
| Chase | Kourtney |
Jordan |
| Anthony | Daniel |
Keauna |
| Kristiana |
Tanner |
Reb |